External wall insulation vs ground source heat pump

When you start thinking about shrinking the carbon footprint of your house, you come across a variety of options. The only way to make a sensible choice is to weigh them up against each other, and work out what brings the best return for investment, both in money and in carbon saved.

gshp

The benefits of a ground source heat pump depend on the amount or space you have and the kind of fuel you are replacing.

In the early phases of our planning for the Westacre Project, we looked into the benefits of installing a ground source heat pump (GSHP). GSHPs extract heat from the ground in your garden to heat your home. The technology doesn’t use any fossil fuels and requires little or no maintenance. In the end we decided not to have one. Why not?

GSHPs work most efficiently in a well insulated home. They work at much lower temperatures than your conventional central heating. The system can’t heat your house effectively if it is draughty or loses lots of heat through solid walls like ours.

Clearly, Westacre’s 1930s house wouldn’t be up to that. We would need to do something drastic to improve our insulation. We are planning external wall insulation and good quality draught-free windows, as well as insulation under the floor and in the loft.

Solidwallinsulation

Installing external wall insulation on your solid walls can save a lot of carbon, and of course, money.

It turns out that installing external wall insulation to a high standard is very effective indeed. If you were to insulate a standard three bed semi that is heated with gas, you could save up to £460 in heating bills and 1.9 tonnes of carbon dioxide per year. That is a significant saving.

Our house is larger and is detached, so our savings will be even greater. We certainly noticed just how leaky it is at the moment when we discovered we were using over £6 a day to heat the whole house during the cold winter.

External wall insulation is not cheap. If you get a contractor in to install the insulation, for that typical semi, it may cost you between £9,400 and £13,000. That’s an eye-watering cost, but our whole aim is to spend the money up front so our house will be very cheap to run and virtually carbon neutral in the long run.

Of course, we could have a ground source heat pump as well. It would work effectively for a well insulated house. But the system is also very expensive: £9,000 to £17,000, and wouldn’t give us that much added benefit.

The typical gas-heated semi mentioned above would in fact lose money from operating its moderately efficient GSHP as compared with just burning gas. If the GSHP was performing at best efficiency, it could save about £110 per year and 850kg of carbon. GSHPs are most effective if you are currently heating your house solely with electricity. If you are in that situation, it could save up to £650 per year.

When Westacre is well insulated, it probably won’t need as much heating as a GSHP can generate. It would not be worth the extra investment. Just insulating the house well should keep us warm for most average weather conditions. We will have to live with our insulation for a while to work out how much extra heating we will need. For extra cold days, we intend to install backup in the form of solar hot water and a wood burning stove with a back boiler.

Our intention is to make the house as carbon neutral as possible. This obviously will reduce our impact on the climate. But on top of that, it will protect us from any fluctuations in fuel prices in the long run. For now, we may be able to save up to £500 per year, but who knows what our investment will be worth when gas prices rise?

Do you have any experience with either external wall insulation or ground source heat pumps? Please share below.

Sources:
Figures and insulation image from the Energy Saving Trust. Their web site is a great source of information, starting from turning off your lights all the way to generating your own energy.
GSHP image from UGE.

Four Pathways to Connected Living: An Introduction

Westacre’s Spiritual Centre is slowly taking shape. I have written a basic framework for its teaching and put it on the Westacre web site. If it speaks to you, please share it widely. Over time, it will become a great resource for strengthening your soul in times of uncertainty. Click here to go to the page.

Sheep’s wool vs. phenolic board: How we made the choice

Our concern about climate change have led us to an ambitious project. We intend to move our 1930s house into the 21st century by massively reducing its need for active heating.

The main part of this project is improving the insulation. We plan to envelop the entire house in a layer of external wall insulation that keeps the heat inside. For this job, we will use 10 cm thick phenolic insulation board.

You may ask: if you are that concerned about the environment, why are you using a man made material? Why aren’t you going for something natural, like sheep’s wool or straw?

Does it make sense to use a material that ultimately derives from crude oil? Well, for us it does.

Our main restraint is that this project is a retrofit. We are adapting an old house for the future. If we had the means to start from scratch, we probably would choose different materials. As it is, we have a 1930s house that loses heat through its solid brick walls. We need to find a solution that works for us.

The speed at which heat is lost through particular materials is measured in U-values. On average, a solid wall (which is how the main part of the house is built), has a U-value of 2.1. Newly built house walls nowadays have a U-value of 0.3. We are aiming to go better than that, to about 0.23.

What would we have to do to get to that value for different materials?
- phenolic insulation board
- sheep’s wool
– straw bales

1. Sheep’s wool

Wool works best layered between structural elements. (image from www.greenfsonline.co.uk

Wool works best layered between structural elements. (image from www.greenfsonline.co.u

I love the idea of wrapping my house in a nice warm woollen blanket. Natural materials certainly have an appeal, and for some projects, wool would be the right choice.

For retrofit external wall insulation, however, sheep’s wool isn’t practical. This material works best when it is sandwiched between two structural walls, like the two parts of a cavity wall. We would have to somehow attach the wool to the outside of the existing wall, and then build another structural wall outside that.

The U value of 10 cm of wool is 0.42. In combination with our solid brick wall at a U value of 2.11, that brings us to a total of 0.35, which is above the value we’re aiming for. We would have to make the insulation twice as thick to come to our ideal value.*

2. Straw bales

The advantage of straw bales is that they are structural. In other words, you can build a wall with them and it will stay up. It is a great material to build new structures with, as it also has a high level of air tightness. If we were to start from scratch, this would probably be one of our materials of choice.

However, to get to our ideal U value of about 0.2, we’d need to wrap the house in straw to a thickness of 40 cm. That is rather a lot of straw and would give us very thick walls. We would have to extend the eves of our roof quite a long way to cover this.

3. Phenolic insulation board

Phenolic insulation board is light and easy to work with

Phenolic insulation board is light and easy to work with (image from cheerforeduct.en.ec21.com)

Phenolic board is extremely light and easy to work with. So much so, that we are intending to do this part of the installation ourselves. Covered by a mesh and a special render, it is also very durable and flexible.

We will only need 10 cm of phenolic board to come to our overall U value of 0.23. This is a better standard than modern newly built houses.

We calculate that this will be enough to cut out gas central heating all together. With luck, we’ll be able to install the insulation, and the new windows, this year. We need to live with it through the winter to find out how much heating we will actually need.

Here’s hoping that solar hot water, a wood burner, and phenolic insulation board will keep us cosy even in freezing temperatures.

Have you made similar choices? What worked for you? Please share your experiences in the comments below.

*To find out how U values are calculated, click here.

How to insulate your house and cut heating bills

Phase 2 of the Westacre Project is to insulate our 1930s house well enough so that we no longer need gas to heat the house. If all goes well, we should barely need any heating at all.

We have been thinking about and planning this phase for a long time. Retrofitting an old house to significantly reduce its carbon footprint is a complex issue. This will be the most important – and most expensive – part of the project.

The aim is to minimise heat loss. The speed at which heat is lost through particular materials is measured in U-values. On average, a solid wall (which is how the main part of the house is built), has a U-value of 2.1. Newly built house walls nowadays have a U-value of 0.3.

We are trying to end up somewhere in between, hopefully close to the modern standard. To help us achieve this, we have to make the choices that will work for us and for our house.

Here is an overview of the decisions we have made, and our thinking behind it. We hope it will help you as you think through changes you could make.

1. Windows
The first part of the project is to install high quality windows and doors. They will help significantly to cut out draughts and heat loss through the glass.

We are going for aluminium clad UPVC. It’s not the ideal solution, but unlike wood, UPVC fits in our budget. We’ll also avoid having to paint or treat the wooden windows.

The aluminium cladding on the outside will extend the life of the UPVC, so hopefully they won’t have to be replaced for several decades.

We will reduce the window openings at the front of the house, and use triple glazed windows there. The house faces North West, so that side is coldest and gets all of the weather. Smaller windows and triple glazing will help the rooms at the front stay warmer.

On the sunny side of the house, the windows will be double glazed. Triple glazing not only keeps out the cold, it also keeps out the heat of the sun. We want to make use of solar gain to heat the house as much as possible, so thinner glass will help there.

2. External wall insulation
The old part of the house is built with a solid brick wall, which also loses heat. The only practical way to improve its U-value is to install external wall insulation.

We will be cladding the entire outside of the house with 10 cm of phenolic insulation board. It is finished off with a smooth render.

You can add different finishes to your external wall insulation (from www.minsteronline.co.uk)

When installing this insulation, it’s important to envelop your entire living space. Any cracks or cold bridges in the insulation will cause condensation and possible damp problems inside the house.

This means we’ll have to make sure the insulation goes down to the foundations of the house and links up with the loft insulation.

3. The roof
The external wall insulation will make our walls about 12 cm thicker than they are now. To accommodate this, we will need to extend the eaves of the roof.

The bottom few courses of tiles will be taken off, and the joists kinked out slightly so that they extend further, but no lower, than they do now. We are going to need to hire some scaffolding for that job.

At the same time, we’ll also have to modify the roof insulation in a couple of areas where rooms are directly under the roof. An insulated roof space that doesn’t have adequate ventilation is liable to get condensation between the tiles and the insulation.

4. Ventilation
All of the above should give us a very well insulated house with a minimum of heat loss. On the other hand, the insulated envelope will not let in much fresh air, so we will need to provide ventilation.

We have calculated that air exchange through ventilation would be our next biggest source of heat loss. So we intend to install a heat recovery ventilation that pre-heats the cold air coming in.

The system blows out the stale, warm air from inside and sucks in fresh, cold air from outside. The two cross over in a heat exchanger, where the warm air slightly heats the incoming cold air, so the house stays warmer.

Once all this is installed, we’ll have to live with it for a while so that we can work out exactly how much heating we will need. You can make complicated calculations based on theory, but the real proof of the pudding is experiencing how warm it actually feels.

We hope to be able to entirely cut out gas central heating, and warm our house with solar hot water and a wood stove with a back burner. But that is a different story.

More information on home insulation from the Energy Saving Trust is here.

For daily updates and inspiring links, follow us on Twitter.

 

For badgers and for peace: letting the world in

This morning, people started shooting badgers in Somerset and Gloucestershire. It is a ‘cull’, an attempt to stop the animals spreading Bovine Tuberculosis between cattle herds. Scientists gravely doubt the effectiveness of this action. Many are concerned that the cull will in fact disperse surviving badgers and make the situation worse. Still, the killing begins. Also [...]

Electric kettle vs. induction hob

I have a 3kW electric kettle, and a 2kW induction hob, and I find the induction hob faster and more convenient. (My wall sockets are all 240V.)

However, I’ve just actually measured it, and the situation is more complex… I timed how long it took each of them to boil a single cupful of water. Unsurprisingly the 3kW electric kettle boils the water much more quickly, but it takes ages for its temperature sensor to notice. The electric kettle turned off at almost exactly the same time as the stove-top kettle started to whistle.

So for small volumes of water, it’s a draw. For larger volumes of water, the electric kettle is noticeably quicker.

Why then, do I find the stove-top kettle much more convenient? I think it’s because it has a better “user interface”. When the electric kettle has boiled, it clicks off and I often finish whatever else I’m doing before going to use the hot water. By then, it’s usually cooled down a bit, and I have to turn it back on and wait to bring the water back to the boil. (Actual boiling water is very important for making tea.) OTOH, the stove-top kettle whistles and stays boiling, so I am forced to go and deal with it immediately. The result is that I get my tea made a little bit quicker, with less waiting around.

Interesting. Perhaps electric kettles should replicate that UI, by having a continuous alarm, instead of automatically turning off.

Finishing Phase 1

Settling everyone into their new homes has taken a long, long time. Much longer than we ever anticipated. One way or another, we got delayed and exhausted. And on occasion distracted by projects that need doing and require less intricate logistics.

We’re coming out the other end of the exhaustion, though, and ready for the next part of the project.

Here is how Phase 1 went:

1) Finish renovating the bungalow
It took us until the end of February to finish renovating the bungalow to an acceptable standard. But it got done, with walls painted, carpets and wooden floors down, and all the amenities in working order.

2) Move Roger’s furniture and belongings into the bungalow
We had a number of mini adventures doing this. Some bits of furniture had to come downstairs, and we wondered how they ever made it up there. Roger also re-used a carpet from Westacre in his bungalow. This involved passing it out of the 1st floor windown, transporting it on the trailer, and having the professionals lay it in the bungalow. Nobody was hurt, but one light fitting didn’t survive the passage of the carpet through the bung.

3) Let the house in Harrow
When we had moved Roger to the bung, we were ready to go and empty our Harrow home at a leasurely pace. Just then, the agents let us know that the place had been let and we had 10 days to move everything out. We managed, and our tenants moved in and started paying rent. Which is brilliant.

4) Move Alex and Hilde’s furniture and belongings from Harrow to Westacre
We moved our furniture up the M40 by trailer. And we had to do it fast due to the tenants moving in at relatively short notice. It took 6 journeys. Thankfully we found a friend to help us with the heaviest pieces. Thank you Matt!

5) Find new homes for things that are no longer wanted
We tried hard to find someone who had both the time and the patience to help us with this. We failed. In the end, we loaded most of it onto the trailer and took it to a car boot sale. This was a very successful exercise in getting rid of unwanted possessions, and we made some money too. We’re very glad we waited for a nice sunny day, when there were lots of people out for a bargain.

The car boot sale

6) Turning the Westacre living room into a bedsit
We’d been sole occupiers of Westacre for a couple of months before we finally moved into the bedsit. The biggest job was constructing a makeshift kitchen in one corner of the big room. Alex had weeks of fun with electrics and plumbing. It looks very nice from inside the room, but the plumbing going through the (now hidden) kitchen door on the other side of the wall is a bit Heath Robinson. Still, it works. Just a lick of paint on the new partition, and it’ll look like we meant it.

Just a few days ago, we took the first step in Phase 2 of the project: Insulation. We are planning to wrap the entire house in external wall insulation, so the Virginia Creeper had to go. We had the help from our friends who came to stay, and who all got really motivated when they heard we were going to burn it all afterwards. Boys will be boys, whether they’re 45 or 8.

Rage is passion is true love

Full Flower Moon (better late than never!) I can’t even begin to tell you how beautiful it is. Just looking out of the living room window, I see the young green of ash reaching for the sun, the white of cow parsley against the beech hedge, different blues of lungwort and forget-me-not interspersed with oranges and [...]

Virtual connections 14/5/13

Westacre’s bedsit apartment is taking shape. Except for the cooker, we have a fully functioning kitchenette. Tomorrow we’re off for a week in Barcelona, and when we come back we’ll be able to move in and abandon the rest of the house to the renovation project.

To keep you busy while we’re away, here is a list of articles that have caught my attention in the last week or two.

Finding awe in nature

Storms by Ian Hill
Musings in the snow

Finchley Road by Vivienne Palmer
Bumblebees and other minorities in the city

When things fall apart by Sharon Blackie
A life close to the reality of living on and with the land and its creatures. It’s not always an idillic existence.

Climate and environment

Thoughts on the Apocalypse: Fight for what you love by Derrick Jensen
An impassioned appeal to start fighting for our world and all that is precious in it.

The giants of the green world that profit from the planet’s destruction by Naomi Klein
Some large green campaigning organisations are deeply invested in the very carbon heavy industries that are killing the planet.

Climate-warming gas in atmosphere passes 400ppm milestone – interactive
Another sad milestone in a series of sad milestones. We desperately need to turn this around.

Ancestors and spiritual traditions

Complete Inuit shaman life story 1922
A fascinating glimpse into a real life story, in a scene from The Journals of Knud Rasmussen.

Witnessing a South African healer at work
Another real life story from our own times

Archaeologists find earliest evidence of humans cooking with fire
We, and people like us, have been using fire to cook food for a very long time. This may have had a significant impact on our evolution.

A better society

Positive development, a ‘turn around’ strategy for growth and civilisation by James Greyson
Ideas on turning our economy away from made-up measurements to real lasting value.

Does Bhutan hold the recipe for the future of farming?
One country in the world is aiming to grow 100% organic food.

Why parents should leave their kids alone by Jay Griffiths
Modern Western parenting compared to traditional societies. Something we can learn from?

Positive change

This desert miracle can only mean one of two things by Carolyn Silveira
How simple technology can change lives profoundly.

Roots, shoots and seeds: the spear carriers by Charlotte Du Cann
Coming home to small scale, land blessed, natural food.

Why your supermarket only sells 5 kinds of apples by Rowan Jacobsen
Singing the praises of rare and unique apple varieties.

Friends

Sacred Body part 4: Loss by Theo Wildcroft
My friend Theo has written an achingly beautiful series of blog posts for Druid Life. This is just one in the series of 6.